OMG! Claire's dad is..!, spoiler if you haven't seen this yet Options

[ordinaryhero]

I honestly think that Claude being her father, thinking she was dead all these years only to discover that HRG had kidnapped her and raised her as his own would have had a much bigger impact and been a far more complex and interesting story

I agree with that as well. My sister was all like "OMG Claude is the dad!" and it would have given a more in depth look at the character. However, I still love the idea of Uncle Peter! I wonder how everyone else will end up connected to each other. As for the Paire shippings...unfortunatley some people will not be disuaded because of the blood relations...which i find...creepy..anyway, yeah can't wait to see where this goes!

This post has been edited by ordinaryhero: Feb 6 2007, 02:48 PM

[HiroHeroe]

And I soo like the remark from Peter about him remembering the sweet girl from Texas. so cute, Uncle Peter.

I guess there goes anyones hopes for claire and peter hooking up..incest much.

[Sabyr]

I agree. Nathan had enough on his plate. There's already been dropped plot lines with him that should have been explored (the accident that crippled his wife, for example).

But perhaps Chris only had a commitment for a few episodes...

That has been answered. Linderman tried to kill him and he accidentally flew out of his car while it was under attack. it was in episode 10, I believe.

I knew it was Nathan as well, i wasn't even looking at the watch or the ring. I was thinking in terms of good plot twists and storytelling. I was thinking, "Man in a suit... not HRG... not Ted... Definitely not Matt... Peter? No way... NATHAN!" I knew it had to be a character we already knew as well, to make it a great plot twist.

Did it happen when Nathan was in his early twenties, then? Nathan appears to be in his 30s and Peter is in his late 20s I believe.

[cr@sh]

Congrats to who ever guessed right... Atleast all the Cleter theorys are no more.

[258west.com]

That has been answered. Linderman tried to kill him and he accidentally flew out of his car while it was under attack. it was in episode 10, I believe.

I knew it was Nathan as well, i wasn't even looking at the watch or the ring. I was thinking in terms of good plot twists and storytelling. I was thinking, "Man in a suit... not HRG... not Ted... Definitely not Matt... Peter? No way... NATHAN!" I knew it had to be a character we already knew as well, to make it a great plot twist.

Did it happen when Nathan was in his early twenties, then? Nathan appears to be in his 30s and Peter is in his late 20s I believe.

Yes Linderman tried to have him killed becuase he was going to take linderman and their dad to court on Racketeering charges. He flew out of the car as it got hit and his wife wasnt so lucky. He really didnt know what happened. Till later.

[Rhine]

Ok not sure if you guys have already discussed this but did HRG know that Nathan was her father, b/c he said they died in some accident. So when he kidnapped him he knew he had his daughters real dad?

[Tardis Traveller]

Ok not sure if you guys have already discussed this but did HRG know that Nathan was her father, b/c he said they died in some accident. So when he kidnapped him he knew he had his daughters real dad?

Well the Haitian said he didn't know anything about Claire's father so what are the chances of HRG knowing?

[Dr. Chaos]

Excellently done, I have to say.

I certainly considered Nathan a strong contender with all the man whoring and him strutting around giving it up for free and what have you but with the writing of the show so far being good but overall predictable (see the "Peter's gonna die" revelation at the beginning of Homecoming), I was expecting them to go with a safer and easier choice like the omnipotent neigh invisible Linderman or the convenient guest star Claude.

The sad thing about this is you know Nathan isn't going to let her be his daughter. He's going to cut her out of his life as quickly and as civilly as possible and she's going to hate him for a long time. Nathan will redeem himself somewhere down the line as he always does but for now, I fully expect him to try and hide and mask the fact that he's giving his long lost daughter the cold shoulder just to save his job when they meet face to face.

Theres no way Nathan is going to walk away from this with a healthy relationship with Claire.

This post has been edited by Dr. Chaos: Feb 7 2007, 01:23 PM

[Angel_of_the_Des...]

 ino01.gif ( 13.8K ) Number of downloads: 3
Augghhh! Why Nathan?! Don't get me wrong, Nathan is cool in all but.. that doesn't get me upset. Peter is Claire's uncle; that's one huge inconsistonsie in my fan fiction...! *sigh* Mendokusai. (What a pain.)

[Inky1231]

OK I am really going to tick people off with this, but it is possible that it is NOT Nathan. we don't know for sure that the person Nathan was on the phone with was Claire's mom, just like we don't know for sure Isaac was on the phone with HRG telling him about Peter. Claire's mom COULD have called HRG not Nathan and Isaac could ahve called Nathan. It is a trip of video editing to make one believe something and then make a spectacular reveal later. As someone who has studied video making and editing I woulld be surprised to find out they did this as straight forward as it seems.

This post has been edited by Inky1231: Feb 9 2007, 12:56 PM

[twilightessence]

Except that the phone call between HRG and Isaac are consistent. Hence the Isaac: "I found him. I think I found a way to stop him." HRG: "Sylar?" Isaac: "I thought you had Sylar?"

And besides that, Claire's mom said at the end of the phone call last week: "We have to talk, Nathan." So something tells me that it wasn't a "Trick".

Plus, I read a interview where Kring says it was planned all along... Did anyone else see that? And can you give me the link?

This post has been edited by twilightessence: Feb 9 2007, 03:42 PM

[cory72a]

I was thinking about the same thing as inky!

This post has been edited by cory72a: Feb 10 2007, 05:56 AM

[mrbliss]

Nathan will be a horrible father for Claire unless he changes.

Like HRG Bennet is such an amazing, stellar father?

[CelestialMystic]

Nathan will be a horrible father for Claire unless he changes.

Ah, well... at least she has Peter for a somewhat-good role model. And, HRG isn't exactly the best, being an evil genius, is he?

[HeroesHero]

I was in total shock when I saw this happen and it was amazing to see Nathan sit down in his chair with a stunned look on his face..

[Eric in Long Bea...]

(Not that anyone will ever see this post but...)

I did NOT see this one coming! In fact, I had no idea that we had already met Claire's father. Kudos to the writers for the blindside.

[thefatindian]

Like HRG Bennet is such an amazing, stellar father?

ffrom last week's episode [#18], we can see that HRG has been trying his hardest and still is.

This post has been edited by idallia: Mar 3 2007, 01:57 PM

Reason for edit: Spoiler code added

[Sylarfan]

ffrom last week's episode [#18], we can see that HRG has been trying his hardest and still is.

yep

[Eric in Long Bea...]

yep

When you spend 12- 14 years raising a child as your own, I would think you'd develop a high level of affection.

[Naomi Tonks]

Yeah, I still see HRG as a more suitable father.

[Stunt]

Wow, I would of never expected.

Claire is a fire woman's daughter who can heal and has a father that can fly and an uncle that can do all of that.

Damn.