WITH all the wierd coincidences surrounding this charact we will find out that she is actually Sylar and that Sylar is a shapeshifter!

I've also thought about this. It would make sense. I was thinking, What if Sylar was right under his nose.

Maybe Sylar can shapeshift. Although I don't think Eden is Sylar.

I agree that Sylar most probably can shape shift. However, I don't agree that Eden is sylar...yet, I think she's up to something.

She has to know something, she's seemingly a core character...why else would she have so much air time?

Eden went from a no nothing character that just happened to walk into the scene at the right time right place. Now she is everywhere keeping an eye on things. Either she is sylar by some form of shapeshifting or Eden might just have all of those powers. Eden has something to do with this show on a bigger scale than she has now but we will just have to see how her storyline will unfold in the weeks to come.

Shapeshafting is the most boring thing this show could do. Cheap and silly. Just saying.

I don't think Eden is Sylar, or that Sylar can shapeshift but

speculating along those lines... there was that pic of Paul Sylar as an alter boy...

maybe he's Pauline now...

Yeah she is! She talks like a robot.

Yeah, but terribly easy on these old eyes, so I let the acting slip.

Spoiler removed .. sorry ...

Duh. No, not a spoiler at all...

*shakes head*

Unbelievable.

If I may give you an advice, delete that reply...

So if Eden's Sylar, not only does she shapeshift, she can be on two opposite coasts at the same time?

SO Sylar can shapeshift, be in two places at once, and stop time.

Hee.

That is if and only if guy at the FBI is Sylar, Sylar killed the family, that is even the same day as the one on which that happened...and if time would matter on this show.

Not that I'm trying to prove that Eden is Sylar..

It's my belief Eden is NOT Sylar. Firstly, the tape, secondly, the answering machine. Very masculine voice. Thirdly, look at the apartment of Sylar. The writing on the walls is of a man who seems quite unstable and confused about what his vocation is in the world, yet, does certain things he feels needs to be accomplished although they are 'sins'. Also unless Edan holds Hiro's special powers too, there is no way she could clear out the apartment while she is with Mohinder getting the police.

Seriously. Eden, IMO, is really interested. If I were to throw my thoughts on Eden out there, I would say she also is a Hero.

She's a spy for the HRG guy

I agree.

A spy Really hmm maybe interesting he could have spys all over the place I could even be one!

ahhhhh all these theories are confusing the real show and this forum in my brain. blarggggggggg

I'd say to just use Occam's Razor.

Choose the simplest response. Eden is not Sylar. Sylar is someone else.

See? Simple.

Peter is not Sylar. Nathan is not Sylar. Sylar is Paul Sylar.

Even simpler: Sylar is Sylar
And I'm 100% sure that I am right.

Eden is not a plant!

She's a mineral!

J

Ridiculous theory!

In my opinion I dont see her being Sylar, but maybe as a spy or bad guy, bad girl whatever. Its been said before and will be said again Sylar is Sylar we might not have even seen him/her(I mean seen as in the actual face) yet and if it is one of the main characters then well probably be shocked or suprised as to who it is.


Sphinx

Chandra Suresh = Sylar

You silly bastards. Sylar is Magneto, Ice Man, Apocalypse and few others stuck in one...O_o

I agree!



This one not so much!

Why would he have two apt and two maps!

She is very good looking though u have to admit that too if we accept she is terrible (which she can so improve on)

LOL.

Everybody is Sylar

The firefighter Claire saved? Sylar
Ando? Sylar
Micah? Totally Sylar
The QB? Sylar, but only on the weekends

word

-- POSSIBLE SPOILER --



In the preview aired after the Heroes marathon wasn't there a shot of Eden and Mohinder making out?

If so, that would mean you're suggesting SYLAR and Mohinder make out in a future episode.

So, umm... yeah.

The idea that Eden is a spy is more than possible.

But if she has any big signficance besides being a friend of both generations of Suresh's the place I think you should be looking to figure it out is her name.

Eden is too perfect a name, what with it's connotations related to creation and the origins of human life, for it just be a throwaway coincidence.

It's way out there, but I'm putting my money on this... for now.

Not sure how Mohinder could claim the body and such, but I'm thinking with the whole brain thing, maybe Papa Suresh takes the thoughts/personality of the person or who knows.

Of course, Sylar could just be someone else entirely, like maybe "boiling water guy" (BWG) from the previews. Isaac's painting of the boiling water has been around for a while now. *shrug*

As for Eden, I think in the previews at the end of this past Sunday's marathon, there is a shot of HRG and I think Eden is in the background. But it's quick and hard to tell.

If Eden IS a plant, what kind of plant do you think she is? A flower, a vine?

Eden - first woman

Eden - patient zero?

Just a thought...

Eden isn't patient zero, sylar is. And as far as her being a plant or against Mohinder, I don't know. Maybe we're reading too deep into it. She could just be a normal person.

For all intents and purposes this is true, but we actually have very little idea who "Sylar" really is. We're operating on a lot of supposition based on very little evidence. Alot can happen, we just have to wait and see.



I think the "origins of humanity" thing is on the right track.

I dunno about the patient zero thing.

Just for laughs how about this...

Eden is a garden.

What's in a garden?

Plants.

:-)

Bleh. _____ is always Sylar. It's a rule of physics anymore. Truth be told: YOUR MOM IS SYLAR!

I mean why would Eden comment on what Sylar was reading or make it easy for Mohinder to go into the apartment if she was Sylar. It's really, blatantly ridiculous if you ask me.