Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Did Zach and Claire's brother really have their memory erased?
9th Wonders Boards > Episode Discussions > Season One > #11: "Fallout"
Claire
Do you really think the Zach and Claire's little brother got their memory erased? For some reason I just think they were told to pretend not to remember, too. The Haitian seemed to be on Claire's side so he might realize that she probably won't be able to do everything without at least Zach. It may just be very hopeful thinking on my part, though..
sirius14sho
QUOTE (Claire @ Jan 3 2007, 02:36 PM) *
Do you really think the Zach and Claire's little brother got their memory erased? For some reason I just think they were told to pretend not to remember, too. The Haitian seemed to be on Claire's side so he might realize that she probably won't be able to do everything without at least Zach. It may just be very hopeful thinking on my part, though..


I definatly think her brother doesn't remember, and I thinking Zach too. Becuase why not tell Claire? He would only need to act like he can't remeber to Claire's dad, and how often would they come in contact. I hope not though, cuz I liked Zach.
Enohp
QUOTE (Claire @ Jan 3 2007, 03:36 PM) *
Do you really think the Zach and Claire's little brother got their memory erased? For some reason I just think they were told to pretend not to remember, too. The Haitian seemed to be on Claire's side so he might realize that she probably won't be able to do everything without at least Zach. It may just be very hopeful thinking on my part, though..


when i first read that, it sounded like you thought that zach and claire were brother and sister...but eventually i figured out what you were saying.

yeah, i thought zach was pretty cool, but i think his memory is gone, i wonder if shes gonna still try to talk to him still.
The Alternative One
There is no doubt about the memory wipes. Zach and Lyle Bennet have been mind wiped. Their expressions were of people who had no idea what Claire was talking about. I think that Claire is the only one The Haitian pretends to mind wipe.
SuperChick
I'm sure Zach had his memories erased, but I think that Claire will help him make new ones. In the previews, I'm pretty sure I saw Zach with a camcorder in hand. He looked astonished by what he saw at one point. It looked like he was seeing Claire's exploits for the first time. It could be that he held back one of the tapes as well, whether on purpose or accidentally. So, he will know about Claire and be her friend again, regardless of his memory being ereased and, in turn, stay in her story.

Lyle? He won't ever about Claire again unless the writer's deem it benefitting the story. In this case, it proved how HRG had no qualms about rendering his family's minds erased, including routinely doing it to his wife.
Beautiful_Letdown
Gosh I sure hope Zach learns about Claire again.
Though to stay on topic, they both DEFINATELY had their memories erased. It would be kind of cool if Lyle learned again too though.
Ronald
QUOTE (Beautiful_Letdown @ Jan 6 2007, 06:14 PM) *
Gosh I sure hope Zach learns about Claire again.
Though to stay on topic, they both DEFINATELY had their memories erased. It would be kind of cool if Lyle learned again too though.

I would think that Claire would show Zack her powers again because even tho he messed up with the tape, he did try to keep her secret. If Claire shows Zack, then Im sure she would be more cautious about Lyle finding the tape, dont forget she wasnt going to have Zack hold the tape the last time. So if she shows Zack, she deffinately is not going to let him keep the tape. The only person I think she will have to worry about is Matt. He is already on HRG's trail and Claire would be easy pickings without the Haitian around to block her thoughts. Then you also have hana, which would limit the transmission to anybody so, she would lose wireless also. So that would limit her options to a few people she can talk to.
What I don't understand is why Zack was erased. He has already shown that he will keep her secret, even tho he is not good at holding onto anything. But this might not been the first time the haitian visited Zack, just like Mrs. Bennett.
Auburn Red
Well why would they pretend, there wasn't anyone around besides Claire to pretend for.
And if they were, those were some pretty harsh things for Zach to say. dry.gif
steve2112
Their memories were definitely wiped. If the haitian didn't that just increases the chances of HRG finding out. Claire's brother is an idiot. That kid couldn't keep a secret if it killed him.
HeroesEclipse
QUOTE (SuperChick @ Jan 6 2007, 09:56 AM) *
I'm sure Zach had his memories erased, but I think that Claire will help him make new ones. In the previews, I'm pretty sure I saw Zach with a camcorder in hand. He looked astonished by what he saw at one point. It looked like he was seeing Claire's exploits for the first time. It could be that he held back one of the tapes as well, whether on purpose or accidentally. So, he will know about Claire and be her friend again, regardless of his memory being ereased and, in turn, stay in her story.

Lyle? He won't ever about Claire again unless the writer's deem it benefitting the story. In this case, it proved how HRG had no qualms about rendering his family's minds erased, including routinely doing it to his wife.

Was about to mention that too. In the new preview Zach has his cam with him and looks in amazement again. Claire wants that friendship back
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.