QUOTE (Marlique @ Oct 11 2007, 06:08 AM)

First, you've got amazing "powers" of observation! :D I'd noticed that myself before, that the powers people get are often very much linked to their trials, tribulations, and personalities. But I really hadn't pushed the reflexion to as many characters as you have.
BUT!
And there is a "but".
Saying that the power they "get" is activated by a situation that they face means we're talking about intelligent design rather than evolution.
I.E. if giraffes spontaneously got longer necks, out of the blue, over the space of a generation because there was no more food available for them at ground level - this means some sort of higher conscience inside of their cells made the trait of the "long neck" appear in their code when it wasn't there before. This is intelligent design.
Evolution on the other hand works very differently. In the context of evolution, if over a generation, food on ground level rarefies, then the giraffes with shorter necks will die of starvation before they are in age of reproducing, while the ones with slightly longer necks will survive, dramatically but gradually changing the genetic pool. (Stress the fact that the population of giraffes already had the genetic possibility of having a longer neck. Same goes with the powers - they must have already had them, from the point of view of evolution.)
Evolution doesn't mean you "get" what you need according to your immediate needs, it means that people with powers would survive more easily to the situations they are facing, and the ones without abilities would die before being able to reproduce, which means the genetic pool would change and the proportion of people with abilities would greatly increase. For example, any baby Claire's age would have died in that fire instead of surviving and being able to reproduce (with West? Ugh.) and therefore transmit her genes.
ALTHOUGH, the fact that characters seem to get abilities suited to their particular situations is a great poetic trait of the show (and by poetic I am talking about the format, the way the fiction is developed). If you want to develop themes in fiction, you don't always have to justify it by scientific theory or logic (after all this isn't a classic case of science-fiction). To make the show more, well, awesome :D (devoted fan here), it's good to have these little bits of apparent logic here and there that "seem to make sense" on a whole other level (i.e. Claire is in a fire and therefore she gets regeneration), the level of fiction, rather than make sense on the level of the theory of evolution. Aristotle said it - the greateness of fiction resides in its capacity to make sense of seemingly unrelated events, and change temporal juxtaposition into a relationship of necessity and causality between events.
When you think about it, we notice the situations in their lives because their powers help them cope with them - this is evolution. It doesn't mean the immediate situations trigger a certain type of ability. It only means Heroes is showing us how these new powers are "evolution" in the sense that these people with abilities are better suited than the rest to cope with hard situations.
All true. However, the nature of the show provides the capacity for us to hypothesise rational explanations for these poetic traits. That's what I love about it! Let me have a go at offering some explanations...
Activating Evolution:
1) The example of Claire and West echoes the relationships of Nathan & Merideth and DL & Niki and illustrates that Heroes attract Heroes. This is evolution! Both those former relationship spawned early-presenting individuals... And Molly is destined to marry Micah! Just kidding.
So, under the mechanism of sexual selection, the species could at least be diverging, those mutually attractive overachievers begetting more and more super-powered kids. This is quite an interesting idea!
2) It could be that in fact each of the Heroes has an identical genetic adaptation which gives them the predisposition to manifest a superpower for survival purposes. (Could they also manifest a power that increases their reproductivity? Makes them irrestibly attractive perhaps?). All the Heroes' power could be explained like this, even Peter's and Sylar's where their adaptation has specifically manifested - because of their respective personality traits! - as an ability to acquire others' talents.
The problem with this is that it's a big ask of genetics and science in general to achieve the kind of things these guys can achieve through their powers. But is it impossible...?
This is where it starts getting really interesting. The world we see in Heroes seems to imply the hand of some higher consciousness. Obviously that's because there's a team of writers creating a fascinating and exciting epic, but I don't think Heroes is going to reveal (in the controversial season 5 finale) that the ultimate force guiding it al is the almighty King Trim. Who are the story-internal agents of the apparent intelligent design?
Some god-like possibilities:3) Maybe there's a source. An origin. a single mutation so improbable but so significant that even though it has occured only once, it has been able to propagate and facilitate the Hero phenomenon.
4) Maybe it's the characters themselves. With Mohinder's genetics, Hiro's time and space, and various powers via Peter (Charlie's memory, Sylar's intuitive aptitude) or an even greater combination, couldn't they mastermind the whole thing? Let's face it, Peter can travel in time and space. He can get any powers that anyone's ever had. And combine them. Surely that's enough power to write history... He could also get Linderman's power and use it to save Heroes. And then transport them through time and space...
5) Maybe it's the company, how long has this still-very-mysterious organisation been around?
6) Maybe there's another evolutionary imperative - an evolution of possible worlds: those that are more meaningful, that have the more significant connections are those which persist. So despite Peter's hypothetical omnipotence, his powers have a will of their own... Despite Hiro's actions and his ability to effect changes there are still inevitable convergences...
7) But whatever the source, it make would sense to use an eclipse - "a global event" - as a trigger. These are regular, predictable and provide a robust cycle... it's almost like an astronomical clock. Does the intelligent design bear the marks of the master clockmaker? Or any individual or organisation who wanted to reset their systems? Or are they built by evolution into biorhythms like solar and lunar cycles? Or do they provide quantum convergences of a galactic scale?
I love the way that in ep1 it was clear that Hiro had thrown a spanner in the works of history,
...in ep2 it was obvious he would solve this by becoming Takezo Kensei,
...and in ep3 he has restored Takezo Kensei to the role of supernatural hero of mediaeval Japan!
Are we going to find out who the swordmaker is?
I'm enthralled by the way they can keep us guessing. Lead us one way then the other, but leave all of these options open. And lay clues, suggestions, red herrings and foreshadowings all over the place!