Now, if a person on HEROES could actually "reset" time, so if it's as if the whole world's perspective were from 1 year ago according to the time in the HEROES 'verse (like when Superman spun the world on its axis the opposite way), then
maybe there'd be a different outcome.
Yet, then, the show would be different or ending with Arthur in power...

Also, the writers choose the stories, and this is how they wanna portray HEROES.